Peer Review Process

EDITORIAL POLICY

All manuscripts submitted to J-ROEI undergo a double-blind peer review process to ensure quality, originality, and scientific integrity.

Policy Overview

J-ROEI uses a double-blind peer review process, meaning both the author and the reviewer remain anonymous to each other. Each manuscript is reviewed by at least two reviewers who are experts in the relevant field. This standard is essential for supporting future indexing applications (DOAJ, SINTA, Scopus).

Review Process

1

Initial Submission

Authors submit their manuscript through the OJS platform.

2

Editorial Screening

The editor checks the manuscript for scope compliance, formatting, and plagiarism (via Turnitin). Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's requirements are rejected at this stage.

3

Reviewer Assignment

The editor assigns the manuscript to at least two reviewers who are experts in the relevant field. A third reviewer is appointed if there is a significant disagreement between Reviewer 1 and Reviewer 2.

4

Peer Review

Reviewers evaluate the manuscript based on originality, methodology, contribution, and clarity. They provide feedback and a recommendation to the editor.

5

Editorial Decision

Based on the reviewers' feedback, the editor makes one of the following decisions:

  • Accept — published as is
  • Minor Revision — small changes required
  • Major Revision — substantial changes required
  • Reject — not suitable for publication
6

Revision and Resubmission

Authors revise their manuscript based on the reviewers' comments and resubmit it for further evaluation (re-review is required for major revisions).

7

Final Decision and Publication

Once the manuscript is accepted, it undergoes copyediting and layout before being published online (continuous publishing or per issue in May/November).

Review Timeline

The total estimated review time is 4 – 6 weeks, broken down as follows:

A

Editorial Screening: 1–2 weeks

Initial check for scope, format, and plagiarism.

B

Peer Review: 2–4 weeks

Reviewers evaluate the manuscript.

C

Revision: 1–2 weeks

Authors revise and resubmit.

Ethical Obligation

Confidential: All manuscripts are treated as confidential documents. Reviewers must not share, distribute, or use any part of the manuscript for their own purposes.
  • Reviewers must disclose any conflict of interest and decline the review if necessary.
  • Reviewers must provide objective and constructive feedback.
  • For any questions regarding this policy, please reach out to info@ggmountain.co.id.